AI Visibility Checks

Research · November 2, 2026 · 7 min read

Where ChatGPT and Claude Actually Get Their Local Business Recommendations

The quick answer: when ChatGPT recommends a local contractor, it mostly cites the Better Business Bureau and state licensing sites. Claude mostly cites Yelp. Google Maps, the place most owners put all their effort, was cited in fewer than 1 in 400 ChatGPT answers in a September 2026 study.

That changes where your next hour of marketing should go. Here's what the data shows and what to do about it.

The sources each assistant cited

In September 2026, 8ight.AI asked ChatGPT and Claude “Who is the best [trade] in [city]?” for 39 trades across 49 US and Canadian cities, with web search turned on. This is the share of answers that cited each source:

SourceChatGPT (1,412 answers)Claude (218 answers)
Better Business Bureau38.7%6.4%
Government and licensing sites25.1%0.0%
Expertise.com16.3%22.0%
Angi11.8%25.2%
Thumbtack3.7%19.3%
Yelp0.0%92.7%
Reddit0.4%0.0%
Google Maps or business pages0.2%0.5%

Two assistants, two almost opposite source lists. A business with a perfect Yelp page and no BBB profile can be a regular in Claude and invisible in ChatGPT.

But Google reviews still matter

Google isn't out of the picture. It just works differently. A separate study by Spearleaf looked at the business cards ChatGPT displays in local results across 216 US markets. Of the 799 cards it could match to a rating source, about 83% showed Google ratings and 17.4% showed Yelp ratings.

And review volume tracks closely with being named at all. In the 8ight.AI data:

Google reviewsShare named by ChatGPT
Under 253.4%
25 to 9910.0%
100 to 24913.9%
250 to 99920.9%
1,000 or more22.2%

Star ratings made no difference between the two groups: the median was 4.9 for named and unnamed businesses alike. Volume mattered, not stars. The biggest jump is between under 25 and 25 to 99 reviews, where your odds roughly triple.

So the practical picture: Google reviews help ChatGPT decide you're established and give it a rating to display. The BBB, licensing boards and directories are what it cites as proof.

Mentions beat links

This pattern isn't only local. Ahrefs studied 75,000 brands and found that how often a brand is mentioned across the web correlated far more strongly with AI visibility (about 0.66 to 0.71 across ChatGPT and Google's AI features) than its domain authority did (0.27 in ChatGPT). Mentions on YouTube correlated most strongly of all.

The takeaway for a small business: being talked about on trusted sites matters more than your own site's SEO strength.

What to fix, in order

  1. Claim and complete your BBB profile. Accreditation isn't required to have a profile. Make sure your name, address, phone and services match your website exactly.
  2. Check your license listing. If your trade is licensed, search your state board's lookup for your business. Your name and status there should match how you present yourself everywhere else.
  3. Fix your Yelp page, even if you never get Yelp leads. Claude reads it in almost every local answer. Add hours, services, photos and a description in plain sentences.
  4. Get to 25 Google reviews, then 100. Ask every happy customer, in person or by text, right after the job.
  5. Fill out the trade directories assistants cite: Angi, Expertise.com and Thumbtack, if they fit your trade.
  6. Make your own site readable. Every listing above points back to your website. If AI crawlers are blocked or your services only appear inside images, the trail goes cold. Our free scan checks this in about 30 seconds.

What this data doesn't tell you

The 8ight.AI study covers home-service trades and fitness studios, not restaurants or shops. It used each assistant's API rather than the consumer apps, and its author sells AI visibility services. The patterns are strong, but your market may differ. That's why it's worth running your own check: our guide on how to test whether ChatGPT recommends your business takes about 15 minutes.

FAQ

Does ChatGPT use Google reviews?

It often displays Google ratings on business cards, but it rarely cites Google pages as a source. In the September study, Google Maps or business pages appeared in 0.2% of ChatGPT's answers.

Does ChatGPT use Yelp?

Rarely as a cited source: 0.0% of ChatGPT answers in the 8ight.AI study. It did display Yelp ratings on 17.4% of matched business cards in the Spearleaf study, more often for plumbers and in Los Angeles.

Where does Claude get local recommendations?

Mostly from Yelp, cited in 92.7% of Claude's local answers, followed by Angi, Expertise.com and Thumbtack.

Do I need BBB accreditation to show up in ChatGPT?

No study has shown that accreditation itself matters. A complete, accurate BBB profile is the part assistants can read and cite.

How many reviews do I need?

There's no hard cutoff, but businesses with under 25 Google reviews were named only 3.4% of the time, against 20.9% for those with 250 to 999.

See where your site stands, free

Your listings point AI to your website. The free AI Visibility Scan shows whether AI can read it when it gets there: a score out of 100, an A to F grade and your top three issues.

Run my free scan →

Sources: 8ight.AI study via PPC Land, October 2026 · Spearleaf, September 2026 · Ahrefs, 75,000-brand study

Written by the team at Kesem Marketing, a digital agency helping small businesses get found in the AI-first era. Last updated November 2, 2026.

Where ChatGPT and Claude Actually Get Their Local Business Recommendations · AI Visibility Checks